2006-08-23_Agenda Packet--Dossier de l'ordre du jour,z 3� °�
����
AEP
T TO COMMON COUNCIL
July 27, 2006
His Worship Mayor Norm McFarlane
and Members of Common Council
Your Worship and Members of Common Council:
SUBJECT: Community Consultation Survey Results
BACKGROUND
2eelk
The City of Saint John
Through an April 10, 2006 resolution of Common Council, staff was asked to
engage the Community in consultation and that the information collected be used
as background during a Common Council priority setting session.
As a first step in consulting with the Community, staff prepared and distributed a
survey during a two week period in May, 2006. Community groups were asked to
distribute the survey to their membership and the survey was available to the
general public on the City of Saint John's web page or by obtaining a copy from
the Cashiers Office located at the Lobby Level of City Hall.
Attached for your information is a report, Community Consultation Survey
Results, which summarizes the survey responses.
Respectfully submitted,
Kim Graham
Program Manager Vision 2015
Pdtrick Wood
s
Deputy City Manager
REPORT TO COMMON COUNCIL
August 23, 2006
_d
w°
His Worship Mayor Norman McFarlane and The City of saint John
Members of Common Council
Your Worship and Councillors:
RE: Discussions on Role of Council
On July 10, 2006 Common Council meeting in open committee began discussions with
Mr. Stu Baker regarding the role of Common Council. A series of slides is attached
which attempts to capture the essence of the points discussed during this session.
The meeting concluded with Stuart presenting a possible role proposition for Council that
being "Leading Sustainable Growth ". The purpose of the next discussion with is to
revisit this role proposition and see if any questions have arisen since the first discussion.
Following that Stuart will facilitate a further discussion on the implications of this role
and how Council can take steps to "make it real ".
We look forward to your participation in this discussion which will provide key
background for the governance project that is currently under -way associated with Vision
2015.
Respectfully submitted,
Mlf
An 9w P. Beckett C.A.
Deputy City Manager
Terry L. Totten FCA
City Manager
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
City of Saint John
Vision 2015
Role of Council
Process
Value Audit
Value Proposition
Make It Real
• Organization
• Property /Product
. Personality
Live The Proposition
Communicate to Citizens
Evolve — Measure Success
U
Observations
Due to fiscal pressure City Hall's cultural emphasis
has reacted to transactional need.
• There is no single entity dedicated to policy
development as a whole.
• There are no "Evolving" based areas.
Value Audit
ENRICH
DEMOCRAC
4
SUPPORT ECONOMIC
Supportive
Horticultural
Public Library
Parking Commission
Aquatic Centre
Harbour Station
Saint John Water
Transit
Energy
Waterfront Development
Trade & Convention
Centre
Solid Waste
Airport 6
Port
Economic
Enterprise SJ
Tourism
NE Museum
Arts Centre
Imperial Theatre
Enrich
UNB
Opportunity
• Align the governance function with desired policy
outcomes and the respective productive cultures.
• Form /Promote organizations that will fulfill the policy
goals by interacting with the public.
Value Audit
Recommendation Summary
• The core purpose of City Hall is to develop policy
around three outcomes and six determinants for
each outcome.
• The outcomes are Personal Freedom, Wealth
Development and Evolutionary.
• All "transactional' relationships should be organized
with the purpose of fulfilling policy.
0
10
Policy Outcome # 1
Personal Freedom (Supportive Sector)
The ability for individuals to engage with the community
and contribute.
Determinants:
Safety
Shelter
Skills
Mobility
Health / \
Inclusion
a�
Personal Freedom - Culture
Value
Attribute
Benefit
Honest
Trustworthy
Can count on
Industrious
Hard work
Gets job done
Friendly
Considerate
Enjoyable
Loyal
Dependable
No arbitrary change
Traditional
Original
Classic
12
Personal Freedom —Transactional Organizations
• Organizations that promote equal access
to their service.
• Equal opportunity is more important than
operational efficiency.
• The inclusion and independence of all
citizens is the priority and deemed a public
good.
13
Policy Outcome # 2
Wealth /Trade (Economic Sector)
Develop financial resources through trade and provide
material wealth.
Determinants:
Financial Investment
Workforce /Ideas
Workplace
Access
/ \ Business Climate
Network
14
Wealth Development - Culture
Value
Attribute
Benefit
Competitive
High Intensity
Winner
Confident
Self- Assured
Takes Risks
Driven
Uncompromising
High Quality
Decisive
Specialist
Best at Craft
Committed
i
Focused
Reaches Goals
Logical
Rational
Efficient
Wealth Development — Transactional Organizations
Organizations that are "for - profit' and base
their success by their ability generate wealth
in the market place through trade.
• Organizations that directly support the
development of trade or represent market
organizations.
16
Policy Outcome # 3
Evolutionary (Enriching Sector)
Create better ways to be as a society.
Determinants:
Safety /Stability
Skills/Workforce
Shelter/Workplace
Mobility /Access
Health /Business Climate
Art
17
Evolutionary - Culture
Value
Attribute
Benefit
Honest
Trustworthy
Can Count On
Passionate
Dedicated
Inner - directed
Quality
Holistic
Balanced
Sustained Growth
Spiritual
Centered
Do What's Right
Evolutionary
Future Oriented
Try New Things
Simplicity
Uncomplicated
Easy to Use
Inductive
Creative
Better Ideas
Inclusive
Cooperative
Win/Win 18
Evolutionary Transactional Organizations
*Organizations that primarily generate ideas
and suggest how we can better.
• Organizations that are constantly attempting
to redefine "truth ".
IS
Policy Outcome Summary
Personal Freedom
wealth Development/
Trade
Evolutionary
Safety
Financial Investment
Safety /Stability
Skills
Workforce /Ideas
Skills/Workforce
Shelter
Workplace
Shelter/Workplace
Mobility
Access
Mobility /Access
Health
Business Climate
Health /Business Climate
Inclusion
Network
Art
zo
Process
1) Value Audit
2) Value Proposition
3) Make It Real
• Organization
• Property /Product
• Personality
4) Live The Proposition
5) Communicate to Citizens
6) Evolve — Measure Success
2,
Value Proposition
(Role for Council)
• Leading Sustainable Growth
City Hall will lead sustainable growth for Saint John
and work with surrounding municipalities to lead
sustainable growth for the region.
22