The URL can be used to link to this page

2006-08-23_Agenda Packet CANCELLED--Dossier de l'ordre du jour ANNULÉCityof SaintJohn CommonCouncilMeeting Wednesday,August23,2006 Location:CommonCouncilChamber CommitteeoftheWhole 1.CalltoOrder–5:00pm 8thfloorboardroomCityHall 1.1KimGraham-PublicConsultation 1.2StuartBaker-TheRoleofCouncil Cityof SaintJohn Séance duconseilcommunal Lemercredi23août2006 Emplacement: Salle duconseilcommunal Comitéplénier 1.Ouverturedelaséance:17h 8iéme étageHôteldeville 1.1KimGraham–consultationpublique 1.2StuartBaker-lerôleduconseil- July27,2006 HisWorshipMayorNormMcFarlane andMembersofCommonCouncil YourWorshipandMembersofCommonCouncil: SUBJECT:CommunityConsultationSurveyResults BACKGROUND ThroughanApril10,2006resolutionofCommonCouncil,staffwasaskedto engagetheCommunityinconsultationandthattheinformationcollectedbeused asbackgroundduringaCommonCouncilprioritysettingsession. AsafirststepinconsultingwiththeCommunity,staffpreparedanddistributeda surveyduringatwoweekperiodinMay,2006.Communitygroupswereaskedto distributethesurveytotheirmembershipandthesurveywasavailabletothe generalpublicontheCityofSaintJohn’swebpageorbyobtainingacopyfrom theCashiersOfficelocatedattheLobbyLevelofCityHall. Attachedforyourinformationisareport,CommunityConsultationSurvey Results,whichsummarizesthesurveyresponses. Respectfullysubmitted, KimGraham ProgramManagerVision2015 PatrickWoods DeputyCityManager c en o~ ~ ::J co en ~ Q) ::JO::: en c ~ o Q) U C ~::J ~cn C ::J E E o U z = o ~ ~ z ~ rJ) LO ~ o N C o -- en -- > .-- j ". I fJ ; . ~; 1 c 0 -- +-' CO E s..... 0 '+- C - -c c ::J 0 C ""0 s..... C) 0 0) -- ..c c en +-' 0 ~ ()) ()) -- t) 0 ~ +-' CO CO ()) en ~ ~ a. m -- 0 E ()) ()) u a. 2:: 2:: -- z CO t i :r: s.... L!) ~~ ::J ()) ::J ::J CO "t"""" 0 a... I- C/) C/) a... C\I c 0 II II II II II Cf) ~ :> c o -- +-' CO E s..... o '+- C - -c c ::J o s..... 0) ~ t) CO CO _ Z i :r: ~~ ~ CI) s.... +-' CI) C s.... CI) ..ccO C 0> ..c " - CI) CI) o I 0 t) J ..c en en s.... +-' "2> ~ C ::J CI..c CI) 0 "m t) N ~ C/) C ~ +-' ,y ..c co 0 L.L.. UJ~~s....~J O+-,+-, 0 oC/) :::::> C C "- "- CO 0:: "m "m 53 53 z c...C/)C/)C/)C/):::::> . . . . . . ~ t CI) > o CI) q. "'C +:i +-' co C E ~ <( E \f- en CI) ::J 0 en > C/) "'C (1)" - C \f- s.... c+-'o o en co "w"~ "w 0:: t 0 ::J ~ ::J <(<(CO COC u.. .... . ~ s.... o S C +-' ..c CI) o Z Jt+-' c 0 CI) "- c.. C co c..:C C/) ::J co C C/) 0 S C ..c o co +-' c.-E ~ :::::>:::::>>- . . . +-' C CI) E c.. o - CI) CI) > 0> CI) C o co ..c c== en 0 co t) "c E 3 co UJ ::J 0 "~ Z IO~O . .. J!f.>>-- j fi- '. I '" , . ~; 1 L!) "t"""" o C\I c o Cf) :> en +-' - ::J en Q) 0::: ~ Q) C ::J en _ Z i :r: ~~ ~ J!f.ti-- j fi- '. I '" , . ~; 1 L!) "t"""" o C\I c o Cf) :> CommunityConsultation Survey Results 1 LIFEINSAINTJOHN Percent 1. Intotal,howmanyyearshaveyou livedintheCityof SaintJohn? Response 0-921% 10-1915% 20-2918% 30-3917% 40-4916% 50-5911% 60+3% 2.Otherthanfamilyandfriends,whatdoyoulikebestabout livingin SaintJohn? Top10bestthingsaboutliving Percent Reasonswhy Response in SaintJohn… PeopleFriendlypeople13% OurGeographyGoodlocation,every thingisclose,smallsize11% Beautifulwaterfront,close to theharbour, AccessToWaterfront10% ocean,rivers,andlakes LifestyleRelaxedatmospherewithagoodqualityoflife9% Close tonaturalsurroundingswithmanyparks AccessToNature7% andgreenspace Heritage AndHistoryHeritage,historyandarchitecture7% CostOfLivingReasonablecostofliving6% Arts,Culture, And EntertainmentActivities forallinterests5% ClimateModerate,not toohotorcold4% EmploymentGoodjobs4% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 2 2.Otherthanfamilyandfriends,whatdoyoulikebestabout livingin SaintJohn? Percent TopThreeCombinedAnswersReasonswhy Response Natural Environment– theaccessibilityof 1.19% nature,water,andparks 2.Peopleand the SpiritinourCommunities17% Arts,culture,heritage,andentertainment 3.16% coupledwith theCity’smanyattractions 3.Whatspecificcommunityattributesdoyouvalueabout SaintJohn? Top10communityattributes Percent Reasonswhy Response valuedaboutSaintJohn… Caringcommunitywilling tohelp,where Community Spirit22% neighbourscareaboutneighbours PeopleFriendly,generous,andhardworkingpeople18% Ability tolookat the futurewithoutdismissing Heritage AndHistory10% thepast Passionateaboutlocalareas– the Arts Services And AttractionsCentre, ImperialTheatre,CityMarket, King8% Square,andMuseum Culturaldiversity, theuniquenessof Saint Arts,Culture, And EntertainmentJohn,availabilityofliveentertainmentat the8% Imperialandother theatrevenues Thesurroundingnaturalbeauty,parksand AccessToNature8% naturalspaces Thewaterfront,itiswhatmakes SaintJohn AccessToWaterfrontuniqueandholds themostpotentialasa7% showcaseattribute SafetyFeelsafein SaintJohn4% “SmallTown” feelingina“BigCity” Lifestyleenvironment, SaintJohnmixesa fastpaced,4% urbanlifestylewithslowcountrysurroundings Sports-close tohockey,soccer, football,and Recreation3% manyrecreational facilities CommunityConsultation Survey Results 3 3.Whatspecificcommunityattributesdoyouvalueabout SaintJohn? Percent TopThreeCombinedAnswersReasonswhy Response 1.Peopleand the SpiritinourCommunities40% Arts,culture,heritage,entertainmentcoupled 2.27% with theCity’smanyattractions Natural Environment– theaccessibilityof 3.15% nature,water,andparks Percent 4.Howwouldyouratetheoverallqualityoflife inyourneighbourhood? Response Excellent23% Good44% Fair25% Poor8% DoNot Know0% Percent 5.Howwouldyouratetheoverallqualityoflife intheCityof SaintJohntoday? Response Excellent5% Good45% Fair31% Poor18% DoNot Know0% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 4 Percent 6.Comparedto5yearsago,doyoufeelthequalityof life in SaintJohn is: Response Much Better10% SomewhatBetter40% AboutThe Same23% SomewhatWorse12% MuchWorse12% DoNot Know3% 7.Thinkingaboutthequalityoflife in SaintJohn5yearsfromnow,doyouthinkit Percent Response willbe: Much Better24% SomewhatBetter35% AboutThe Same22% SomewhatWorse5% MuchWorse11% DoNot Know3% 8.Basedonyourknowledgeand/orperceptions,pleaseratetheoverallqualityof Percent Response lifein SaintJohntoday incomparisontothefollowingcities: ComparedtoMoncton, Saint John’squalityoflife is… Much Better12% Somewhat Better23% The Same13% SomewhatWorse26% MuchWorse16% DoNot Know10% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 5 8.Basedonyourknowledgeand/orperceptions,pleaseratetheoverallqualityof Percent Response lifein SaintJohntoday incomparisontothefollowingcities: ComparedtoHalifax, Saint John’squalityoflife is… Much Better4% Somewhat Better15% The Same12% SomewhatWorse36% MuchWorse25% DoNot Know9% ComparedtoFredericton, Saint John’squalityoflife is… Much Better12% Somewhat Better20% The Same23% SomewhatWorse23% MuchWorse13% DoNot Know9% 9. Ingeneral,howhasthequalityoflife in SaintJohnchanged inthepast5years Percent Response incomparisontootherMaritimecities? Improved24% Worsened32% NotMadeGainsOrLosses26% DoNot Know18% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 6 CHALLENGESIN SAINTJOHN 10. Inyouropinion,whatarethethreebiggestchallengesfacing SaintJohntoday? Top10challengesfacing Saint Percent Reasonswhy Response Johntoday… Employmentopportunities,balancedpolicy, EconomicDevelopment14% diverseeconomy Environmental IssuesAirandwaterpollution,harbourcleanup13% Roads,waterdistributionandquality, InfrastructureRenewal9% transportationnetworks Overcomingnegativeattitudesandimage ChangingMindset9% perceptionsof theCity,need tobereceptive to newideas LeadershipPoliticalleadershipandlackofvision7% PovertyPovertylevelandsocialissues6% Need tobeable toattractandretainyoung NeedsOf Youth6% people Keepingourpeoplehome,alongwithbringing Populationthemback,wehavelostsomanyofour family5% and friends tootherplaces Financial IssuesChallengeof funding, taxrate5% CommunityDevelopmentPlanning,neighbourhoodrevitalization,policy5% 11. Inyouropinion,whatwillbethethreebiggestchallengesfacing SaintJohn10yearsfrom now? Top10challengesfacing Saint Percent Reasonswhy Response John inthefuture… Retainingandattractingbusiness,employment EconomicDevelopment19% opportunities Environmental IssuesAirandwaterquality(harbourcleanup)13% Roads,waterdistributionandquality, InfrastructureRenewal12% transportationnetworks PopulationAttractandretainpeople,agingdemographic11% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 7 11. Inyouropinion,whatwillbethethreebiggestchallengesfacing SaintJohn10yearsfrom now? Top10challengesfacing Saint Percent Reasonswhy Response John inthefuture… Financial IssuesFinancialdifficulties, taxrate, funding7% NeedsOf YouthKeepingouryouth4% HousingAffordablehousing4% LeadershipPoliticalleadershipandlackofvision4% PovertyPovertylevelandsocialissues4% Continueddevelopment,improvements to CommunityDevelopment4% uptown,neighbourhoods,andattractions 12.How importantdoyoufeeleachofthefollowingissueswillbecome intheCity inthenext 10years? Important, CriticallyNotDoNot Issues butnot ImportantImportantKnow Critical Enhancing theLocalEconomy 79%19%1%1% FocusingOnSocialIssues(Poverty, 74%21%4%0% NeedsOfYouthAndSeniors,Diversity) NaturalEnvironment 69%27%3%1% MaintainingAStrongUrbanCore 64%30%5%1% WaterSupply 62%30%6%2% CommunityParticipation InThe 56%35%9%0% Decision MakingProcess Encouraging Innovation InThe 55%36%8%1% Community PublicTransit 55%39%5%1% Housing 51%42%6%2% ProvisionOfParksAndGreenSpaces 50%46%4%0% DevelopmentOfNeighbourhoods 50%39%9%2% CommunitySafety 46%46%6%1% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 8 12.How importantdoyoufeeleachofthefollowingissueswillbecome intheCity inthenext 10years? Important, CriticallyNotDoNot Issues butnot ImportantImportantKnow Critical TransportationNetworks 45%45%7%3% EnergySupply 41%45%10%4% ProvisionOfRecreationFacilities 40%51%8%1% AccessibilityOfCommunity 33%56%10%1% Centres/Facilities ProvisionOfLeisureActivities 31%57%11%1% AdequateAccessToArts/Cultural 27%56%16%2% Opportunities 13.WhatcantheCityof SaintJohndotomake iteasierforyoutovoiceyouropinionson community issues? Percent TopFiveAnswersReasonswhy Response CommunityMeetingsTownhallmeetings,sitevisits,openhouses19% SurveysOrQuestionnairesSurveys,polls,questionnaires13% WebForumsOnline forums,opinions,and feedbackpages12% ListenListenandrespond toissues11% Opencommunication,provideinformationon Provide Information7% whatisbeingdone CommunityConsultation Survey Results 9 SERVICESIN SAINTJOHN 14. Ingeneral,howsatisfiedareyouwiththeprogramsandservicesprovidedby Percent Response theCityofSaintJohn? Completely Satisfied2% Mostly Satisfied57% MostlyDissatisfied23% CompletelyDissatisfied10% DoNot Know8% 15.Overthe lastyear,whatcityservicesordepartmentshaveyoucontacted, ifany? Percent Top10AnswersReasonswhy Response Works,water,sewerage,snowremoval, MunicipalOperations30% sanitation,roads,sidewalks,… CityCommissionsParking,Transit, Industrial Parks, SJ Energy11% PoliceCommissionComplaints,reportcrime10% Leisure ServicesParks,recreation7% Building InspectionPermits,inspections,by-lawenforcement7% Planning AndDevelopmentPlanning,zoningregulations6% Cultural AffairsOrHeritageReasonsnotspecified5% MayorOrCouncilReasonsnotspecified5% VariousDepartmentsDepartmentsnotspecified3% OtherJurisdictionsProvincialor federalgovernment3% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 10 Percent 16.Overall,howeasyordifficultwas ittocontactthatserviceordepartment? Response Very EasyToContact26% Somewhat EasyToContact28% SomewhatDifficultToContact11% VeryDifficultToContact5% DoNot Know4% DidNotContact A City ServiceOr 25% Department InTheLast Year 17. Ifyouhaveagovernment-related issue,howclear is itwhich levelof Percent Response government(i.e.Municipal,Provincial,orFederal)youshouldcontact? VeryClear20% SomewhatClear34% SomewhatUnclear20% VeryUnclear16% Never Experienced An IssueOr 7% Question DoNot Know3% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 11 18. InwhatspecificwayswouldyouliketheCityofSaintJohntodemonstrate its accountabilitytothepublic? Percent Top10AnswersReasonswhy Response Openmeetings,responsibleandaccountable Transparency And Accountability23% fordecisions Communicatereasons fordecisions,better Provide Information20% mediarelations,explainobjectives ConsultationPublic forumslike townhallmeetings13% Through ActionFollow throughwithplanning,improveservices12% Annualorregularreportson finances, PeriodicReportCards9% progress,actiononissues OtherSingleitemsuggestions8% Democratic ProcessElections4% GoodJobNowCurrentlydemonstratingaccountability3% Independent AuditIndependentauditmadeavailable to thepublic2% Vision And StrategyHavingavisionwithaplan toachievegoals2% DEMOGRAPHICS Percent 19.What isyourpostalcode? Response SaintJohnCentreand South26% SaintJohnNorthandMillidgeville23% SaintJohnWest22% SaintJohn East15% GoldenGrove4% Quispamsis3% Rothesay3% Rural Areas2% CommunityConsultation Survey Results 12 Percent 19.What isyourpostalcode? Response Grand Bay–Westfield1% RedHead1% Percent 20.Whichoftheagecategoriesdoyoufallunder? Response Under208% 20-3938% 40-5944% 60OrOlder10% No Answer0% Percent 21. Please indicateyourgender? Response Male48% Female52% August23,2006 HisWorshipMayorNormanMcFarlaneand MembersofCommonCouncil YourWorshipandCouncillors: RE:DiscussionsonRoleofCouncil OnJuly10,2006CommonCouncilmeetinginopencommitteebegandiscussionswith Mr.StuBakerregardingtheroleofCommonCouncil.Aseriesof slidesisattached whichattemptstocapturetheessenceofthepointsdiscussedduringthissession. ThemeetingconcludedwithStuartpresentingapossiblerolepropositionforCouncilthat being“LeadingSustainableGrowth”. Thepurposeofthenextdiscussionwithisto revisitthisrolepropositionandseeifanyquestionshavearisen sincethefirstdiscussion. FollowingthatStuartwillfacilitateafurtherdiscussionontheimplicationsofthisrole andhowCouncilcantakestepsto“makeitreal”. Welookforwardtoyourparticipationinthisdiscussionwhichwillprovidekey backgroundforthegovernanceprojectthatiscurrentlyunder-wayassociatedwithVision 2015. Respectfullysubmitted, __________________________ AndrewP.BeckettC.A. DeputyCityManager Programs&Priorities ___________________________ TerryL. TottenFCA CityManager "t"""" c: .c: o .., ..... c: .- ca en .... o ~ ..... .- o II) ~ o N c: o .- tn :> .- (.) c: ~ o o .... o G) o D:: tn tn CD U o a- D. c o +-' en_ ~ 0 m -c c.. (]) ~ e a:: <Ca..+-' (1) (]) (]) ~ ::J ~ - - m ~~~ ....-.... ....-.... ....-.... ~NC') C\I en en +-' en (]) u c U ::J (]) U ""C N ::J cO c+-,C/) o s..... ~ 0 "- a.. +-' U (]) +-'........... +-' m~meno~ "~ t:: cO+-' en c (]) 0 c.. (]) m m c..en em (]) ~ e ID a.. "~ ~ oa..a..(]}c I . . ...c ::J (]) I- E > (]) E - > 0 0 :.:JuJj ....-.... ....-.... ....-.... ~LOc.o C') en .- en co ..c 0.. E ~ CI) t) .- - - co 0 s.... 0.. ::J . tn +-' 0 en ::J +-' co r:: t) . "'C CI) en"'C CI) s.... 0 .. CI) +-' co - CI) co - "'C co t) .- c .- CI) ..... I- "'C en ca ~co CI) co +-' C "'C . ..c c: .- 0 ~CI) o .- .. .. +-' +-' - 0> CI) t) .- 0 co +-'..c c Q) s.... 53 s .- ::J en > en c - tn CI) co 0 en co > CI) s.... - .c s....+-' 0> en UJ 0..0 C co ~ ~ 0 .- - +-' en +-' 0 co "'C 0 C C CI) t) CI) c en +-' E CI) 4= t) en s.... 0.. co co .- 0 CI) (1).Q CI) +-' s.... s.... CI) s.... CI) en CI) > CI) ::J co ..c CI) ..c 0 ..c I-"'C l- . . . ~ .- -a ~ c:c CD ~ ca > J: o - 0::: Z w '<;to - :E o z o o w I- 0::: o a.. a.. ::J en J: o - 0::: Z w o - L!):E o z o o w I- 0::: o a.. a.. ::J en ...... l:: co Q) l:: E l:: .2 0..0 0 tJ) ... .- - ...... .~ l:: ~ Q) l:: E Q) 0 co > Q) ... .- ::> Q) > E~ns> Cl:: Q) 0Q)......l:: ......0...... (J(JCI)..c: l::(J ~ "'0 OaX ~.~ ~ ..., ~ ~ t WU Q) ~ ~ .- ns 0 ...... tJ) C) Q) Q) ... "'C 0 ~ ~ .p l:: l:: Q)'" ...... "'C ~ .- 0........ ... - .- co co co - - ... ... co C'" co co ... l:: ::> ... Q) 0 .- 0 a..<C:I:CI)I-W > I-(JCI)<C a.. CI) ~ > -- co co ... ... ... ... 0 ~ .c ...... .- c. ~ ...J C. (.) (.) .- .- ~ ~ - .c en 0 ~ :I: a.. (.) -- E o r:: o (.) w I'-- ..., (/) Q) tJ) .- ... 0.. ... Q) ...... l:: W E tJ) .- ... ~ o I- .r:: (.) -- ... r:: W 00 OJ Z ::) Q) ... ...... CO Q) EQ)..c: ~l:;1- Q)l::_ tJ) Q) CO ~ U .i: ~tJ)~ OJ~E Z<C ~ ..... .- r:: ~ ~ o c. c. o . ~en t) CI) :.= s.... o ::J o..~ "'C ::J CI) t) s.... CI) .- > en _ (1)~ "'C g ..c"'C ~ 0 s 0.. c CI) .Q > +-' .- t)+-' C t) ::J CI) \f- 0.. CI) en t) ~ c CI) co..c c+-, s.... (1)"'C > C o co 0> en CI) CI) ..c E +-' 0 C t) C>+-' :.= ::J <( 0 . (j) ~ t) .- - o 0.. CI) ..c +-' - - 4= - ::J \f- - .~ c.j .- +-' - co..c ..c ::J +-'0.. en CI) C..c O+-, +:i..c CO+-, N .- .- s C CO 0> C>c s.... . _ ot) CI) CO +-' s.... o CI) Ec e .~ c.....c ........ en E- s.... CO o 0 LLc> . ~ .- -a ~ c:c CD ~ ca > ~ co E E ~ en c: o .- ... CO -c c: Q) E E o u Q) 0:: ~s.... t) .- 0 - \f- o en o..+-, o..C o co - C CI) > CI) "'C o +-' E s.... CI) +-' CI) "'C en >< .- en co I-g ~co +-' en o CI) \f- E o 0 CI) t) en+-' o 0::J . 0.. CI) s.... CI) E ::J CI) 0 o..s.... (1)..cE s.... +-' ::J 8 -g 0 (1)::J..c ..ce~ I- co CI) . ..c +-' co CI) $ .. E o "'C CI) CI) . s.... C' ~ co co C C 0 o~ en_ s.... 0 CI) > c...w ~"'C co C en co (1)+-' E 53 o E Eo.. ::J 0 o CI) CI) > ..c CI) 1-0 . o "t"""" "'C CI) N .- C co 0> s.... o CI) ..c "'C - ::J o . ..c~ en t) .- en- 0..0 .- 0.. ..co> ~ C 0= +:i4= co- _ ::J (1)\f- s.... \f- .. 0 .. - CI) co en 5 0 .- 0.. +-' s.... t) ::J ffi 0.. C CI) co..c s.... +-' +-' ::: ..c - +-' - <( S . ~ "t"""" +-' "t"""" C ::J E E 0 t) CI) ..c +-' ... ..c 0 ... +-' (.) S CI) CI) en 0> CI) CO > 0> -- C ... ... CI) 0 0 +-' ~.!!2 en CO ~ ::J "'C =It E .S; CI) o .- -c-g E . CI) .- CI) 0 CI) s.... +-' (.) ... 0 ::J u.\f-..c - - ... tJ) ~ ~ . s:::: ...... - l:: 0 ns+-'+-' :.= C co l:: r:: .- 0 l:: Z' ~ o ~ t) .- ... 0 (.) E ~ Q) .- ..c: .- ~CI)"'C ...... ...... tJ) - tJ) -- ... ~ - .- ...... - .c ~ - Q) Q) - CO 0 .- - CI) ..c c ...... co ..c: ~ 0 Q) (.) a.. a..l-co Q) (/) (/) (/) ~ :I: l:: C CD I.. ~ ...... - ~ U I E o -c CD CD I.. LL - CO c: o tIJ I.. CD a.. (() en C\I "t"""" e e (() co e (() ..c 0 0 - u u ..c .- .., +-' "'C ~ en -- e co en ..... s..... Q) ::J ..c ~ co co 0 0 0 s..... - c: u .~ .~ +-' () Q) e .- en ..c OJ e +-' W s..... co (() co () ~ 0 Z (() (() ~ - ~ +-' ..c - Q) ..c s..... co co co t 0 s..... e .., S (() "'C .- :] 0 "'C e en .c S .- .- (() s..... -- +-' "'C en a. 0 I.- en s..... e .., ::J co 0 (() .., I 0 <C s..... () I- - en co ::J ~ e - 0 +-' 0 - co Q) en "'C .- .- ~ +-' (() s..... e .- :] +-' (() 0 "'C - e en .....J co ns 0 ::J .- s..... s..... > I "'C LL l- e - I tn r:: o en en CI) u u co - co ::J c- CI) CI) +-' o E o s.... 0.. -- ... ns N -- r:: ns C) .... o - ns r:: o +-' co ..c +-' . en CI) u c .- .Q 2: +-' CI) ~ en . - s.... C .- co CI) o>..c s....+-' 0.8 -- ... (.) ns tn r:: ns .... l- I E o -c Q) Q) .... u. - ns r:: o ~ Q) a.. . c co ..c +-' +-' C co t o 0.. E CI) s.... o E ~ en u .- c ~CI) +-' .- U C .- ::J : I t CI) ~rn o..C o .Q +-' - co co s.... ::J CI) C-o.. W 0 . u .- - ..c ::J =roc.. \f- co O"'C CI) CI) U E C CI) CI) CI) "'C"'C C (1)"'C o..c CI) co "'C~ c~ s.... "'C 0 C co c o .- en ::J - U C C') "t"""" s.... 0.. CI) ..c +-' en .- en c . (1)"'C CI) N 0 ..c+-'O I-UO> . '<;t "t"""" ...... l:: CI) Q) "'C E Q) .- ...... tJ) ...... > tJ) co co 0 Q) Q) E s.... tJ) > "'C .- - 0.. l:: - U ...... ...... l:: Q) Q) "'C co co (.) (.) tJ) C l:: ... co tJ) ~ .- ~ - tJ) ... CO E (.) 0.. tJ) Q) 0 l:: ~ ~ Q) l:: ! CI) ... CO ... ... .- Q) l:: 0 0 (.) tJ) "'C ...... .- ~ ~ (.) ~ Q) CO Q) L1. <C OJ z s.... C +-' ..c ... 0> 0 ::J ... 0 (.) s.... CI) ..c +-' en en (.) CI) -- t) E s.... ::J 0 0 N r:: en =It 0 CI) (.) s.... CI) W co E .- . CI) t) ..c 0 c +-' (.) -c co co ... ns c CI) ~ ,=4=S 0 ....... 0..- ~ = 0 .~ - s.... (.) - CI) CI) -- ns>+-, - 0 CI) CI) co a.. 3:OE Q) L.. ~ ... - ~ o I ... c: Q) E C. o - Q) > Q) C .t: ... - co Q) ~ en ~ .1 . - en ~ co ~ +-' co 0 .- +-' .., s..... en - s..... -- (() .- co () ~ e ..... ~ ::J (() Q) e en a +-' .- c: e en co (() u Q) .- (() ..c :i $ ..c +-' OJ ~ en en u W co .- (() co l- I a:l (() ~ en ~ "'C e .- +-' en .- (() +-' Q) en .- en "'C - s..... E co .., e ::J .- (() :] - e (() en 0 co en .c +-' en s..... .- ::J 0 e a. u .- -- <( U +-' I.- - E (() co .., 0 .., ..c ~ a. ~ <C - 0 en LL en (() .- en u I e :J (() +-' "'C > e (() (() - .- Q) +-' (() e > +-' co .- +-' +-' (() .- u :] "'C .- (() > en E .- - a. \+:: .- en ns .- u e s..... E 0 > E 0 (() 0 0 0 .....J 0 () () () tn r:: o ..c +-' (1)- en co co ~ ..c ;> "'C CI) crn co s.... . .. CI) CI) ~c"'C .- co OCl)s.... s.... 0> +-' 0.. ~..c I +-' ~ s.... . - '-J I o == ::J ~..co ~ co s.... (1)s......c s.... . _ +-' co CI) CI) +-'..cu co +-' co ..c ~_ +-' ..c 0.. en en+-' cenCI) .Q CI) ~ rn 8 coE N ::J .c en CI) COs......c 0> . Ci3 +-' s.... ..c c o +-' ._ -- ... ns N -- r:: ns C) .... o - ns r:: o -- ... (.) ns tn r:: ns .... l- I ... r:: Q) E c. o - Q) > Q) C .r:: ... - ns Q) 3: . +-' CI) ~ s.... CI) co ~ E t+-' o C o..CI) 0.. en ::J ~ en 0.. ~~ +-' s.... ~ 0 .= CI) "'C"'C +-' co co~ ..c\f- +-' 0 . en +-' en c c c o CI) 0 +:iE+:i co 0.. co N N -- 0 -- c - c co CI) co 0>>0> s.... CI) s.... 0"'C0 co "t"""" . I'-- "t"""" Q) +'" ns E .- - Q) U Q) 0 en ns en >. 0 - en en . . +'" s... a. Q) tJ) .- 0 ~ Q) - c ...... .- '+- s... 0 .c ~ .- l:: 0 0 en CO ns s... ~ <C ::J +'" 0 l:: en ....... OJ ~ >. ....... +'" ....... E >. Q) .- .c en - +'" +'" .- +'" ... ~ - - .c Q) - Q) ns .- 0 ~ . ...... ns ~ .c Q) ~ Q) en en en :1E :::c <C +-' C CI) .- ... u 0 0 ... en (.) co CI) en en co r:: CI) -- ..c .r:: 0 M (.) +-' =It -- ... en CI) r:: ~ W co E S 0 s.... (.) ... CI) ... ns +-' ~ r:: +-' CI) 0 0 ..c -- ~ ... CI) (.) ~ +-' - co -- 0 - CI) 0 > s.... a.. wo ... -- 'I- (1) c:: Q) (1) I.. m ~ -.... - ~ o I (1) ... ~~ ns b c: ... o <( .- -.... ~ - o > w (1) ~ - ca > e o +-' e ::J o () e CO () ~ ..c t o ~ en ::J s..... I- +-' en CI) e o I "'C CI) +-' U ~ (1)+-' s..... :.= .- co \? ::J IDa e e "'C CI) +-' co U .- "'C CI) o CI) +-' co e o .- en en co 0... ..c +-' S o s..... ~ "'C CI) e .- co +-' en ::J en "'C CI) u e co - co a:l u .- +-' en .- - o I +-' ..c en .- ~ en .. +-' co ..c S o o "'C CI) s..... CI) +-' e CI) () co ::J +-' .- s..... en en e .- ..c l- S CI) z ~ s..... I- "'C CI) +-' e CI) s..... o CI) s..... ::J +-' ::J LL ~ s..... co e o +-' .0.. ~ en 0 > w CI) en :J o +-' ~ en co W en co CI) "'C s..... CI) +-' +-' CI) a:l "'C CI) +-' co CI) .~ > .- - +-' a. co E CI) o s..... U () e :J ~ +-' .- U .- - a. E .- en CI) > .- +-' U ::J "'C e 00 "t"""" e ~ e .- S CI) > .- +-' co s..... CI) a. o o () CI) > .- en ::J - U e tn r:: o en co CI) "'C .- CI) +-' co s.... CI) . C s.... CI) CI) O>~ ~CI) _..0 .- s.... C co co E u .- s.... CI) ~s co S ~ 0 en..c Coo o ._ CI) +-'0> ~ 0> .- ::J C en co"'C e>c o co . -- ... ns N -- r:: ns C) .... o - ns r:: o -- ... (.) ns tn r:: ns .... I- ~ ns r:: o -- ... :] - o > w 0> C +-' 0.. E CI) +-' +-' co ~ (j) "t"""" +-' C co +-' en c o u CI) s.... co +-' co .. .. ..c ..c +-' +-' en ::J c~ o ::: +:i CI) co C N4= .- CI) C"'C co CI) O>s.... s.... o 0 +-' . ~ ca E E ~ en Q) E o (.) ..... ~ o ~ (.) .- o D.. Q) +"" Q) co ~ ~ Q) u E ~ u co en ns - s..... en .- S u c ..c 0.. Q) 0 CO ~ ~ u en +"" s..... s..... U .- CJ) 0 0 :::f en +'" ::J -.... ~ ~ Q) t - ~ ~ c <( 0 +"" ~ .- ~ en > en Q) .- ::J - W CO - +"" ..c .- m CJ) ~ Q) 0 -.... CJ) ..c ~ ..c CJ) +"" - CO Q) I ~ C +"" Q) c E Q) en E CO Q) a. +"" +"" Q) CO 0 en "'C Q) E - Q) Q) U Q)"'C > -.... CO en .- ~ Q) - > ns c en U s..... Q) s... - U 0.. Q) 0 s..... ~ u en $ 01- - S CO s..... u en 0 +"" .- ~ <( Q) Q) .c u S +'" C s..... C Z - CO 0 .- ns S en Q) c ::J .- 3: u.. m E 0 "'C Q) Q) ~ s... s..... ~ C L1. +"" en Q) ..c ~ - ~ 0 +"" +"" - .- .- - .- ns CO ~ Q) ..c CO en c CJ) CJ) ..c 0 Q) ::J 0 CJ) ~ I u ~ c - Q) a. o C\I tn tn CD U o a- D. c:: o -- ... -- tn -- &. m -g2a:: <ea.+-, (]) (1) (]) ::J ~ ~ - - m ~~~ ....-.... ....-.... ....-.... ~NC') "t"""" C\I en en +-' en (]) u c U ::J (]) U ""C N ::J cO C+-,C/) o s..... ~ 0 .- a.. +-' U (]) +-'........... +-' m~meno~ .~ t:: CO+-' en c (]) 0 c.. (]) m m c..en em (]) ~ e ID a.. .~ ~ oa..a..(]}c I . . ...c ::J (]) I- E > (]) E - > 0 0 :.:JuJj ....-.... ....-.... ....-....O~LOc.o r:: o .- ..... .- tn o C. o .... D.. Q) ~ ca > C\I C\I ..-... C ..c 0"'C J co c~ .m 0 c/)+-' s.... en CI) o ._ \f- +-' .- ..crn +-'0.. s.- . o .~ Co s.... C .r:: O>::J. 0> ~ ~ E ~ ;> ..0 o co 0> CI) ... c.~..c C) . - "'C +-' co C s.... ~ en::J ~ .c ::J 0 ..c ns en t: +-' r:: "'C::J s -i co en 0 ... ~..c 0, tn +-' ~ ~.~ CI) en s~:c C) - s.... co ,.. rnoc _:: I S .m -c +-' ns ~ "'C en CI) ~ c ::J ...J () co en - .- u C ::J o () s.... o \f- CI) - o 0:: '-'" .